Skip to content 
Properties
Below you will find our active property and land listings. Additional area properties are available through our program with the NYS Multiple Listing Service. Spend a day with us to view available properties in our area that meet your specific criteria and needs!
We'll Open Doors for You!
Use the buttons below to sort by category or simply scroll.
- All
- Commercial
- Country
- Land
- Village
- All
- Commercial
- Country
- Land
- Village
Land
TBD Saddlebrook Court
Cooperstown, NY 13326$69,500 5.25 AcresVacant LandOtsego CountyMiddlefield TownshipCherry Valley Springfield School District Submit an Inquiry Welcome to the Country! This property has wonderful views on 5.25 acres with a pond. This parcel provides a sense of place and tranquility.. It is bordered by Shellrock Creek is a river in ...
View Details →
PropertiesVillage
IN CONTRACT – 78 Fair Street
Cooperstown, NY 13326$539,000 3 Bedrooms1.5 Baths1600 SF /.27 AcresBuilt in 1855ResidentialCooperstown Central School DistrictTaxes (School, County and Village) $7,1892 Stories/Traditional Submit an Inquiry CENTRAL VILLAGE LOCATION! Located in a central village location, this village home is in move-in condition and waiting for a new owner. Unique architecture with twin ...
View Details →
PropertiesVillage
76 Fair Street
Cooperstown, NY 13326$599,000 4 Bedrooms3.5 Baths2123 SF /.28 AcresBuilt in 1900ResidentialCooperstown Central School DistrictTaxes (School, County and Village) $5,129Garage with Studio Apt.Historic Submit an Inquiry CLASSIC VILLAGE HOME! This home presents a rare opportunity to do something a little different in your home buying search and process. This home ...
View Details →
CountryProperties
SOLD – 2147 County Highway 33
2147 County Highway 33 is a 17 acre property that truly is in perfect well-maintained condition such as this is incredibly hard to find. A totally restored and renovated home! The inside and the outside of the home have been carefully maintained during the current owners time in the house. ...
View Details →
CountryProperties
530 Ottaway Road
530 Ottaway Road is a country farmhouse, constructed in 1880. The property was expanded in 1990 to twice the size of the original!
View Details →
CommercialProperties
Tunnicliff Inn and Restaurant
32 Pioneer Street Cooperstown, NY 13326 $2,500,000 17 Room Hotel with Private Baths 3 Stories Restaurant and Tap Room on Lower Level 10,406 Square Feet Laundry in Building Restaurant Capacity 86 people Upstairs Dining Room Submit an Inquiry This is a rare opportunity to own an established Motel and Restaurant ...
View Details →
Village
SOLD – 83 Lake Street
Cooperstown, NY 13326 $825,000 4 Bedrooms 3 Baths 3565 SF Built in 1965 Residential Cooperstown Central School District Taxes (School, County and Village) $12,498 1 Story Ranch Style Submit an Inquiry Private Village Location Enjoy the country life without leaving the Village. Situated on 6.34 acres this mid-century single level, ...
View Details →
Village
SOLD – 37 Averill Road
Cooperstown, NY 13326$399,500 ***SOLD*** 7 Bedrooms4 Baths2464 SF.44 AcresBuilt in 1970ResidentialCooperstown Central School District2 Stories Submit an Inquiry A Village Home in a Country Like Setting This house presents many opportunities! It could be a large one family, a two family or a shared rental. Its 7 bedrooms, 4 ...
View Details →
Village
SOLD – 41 Lake Street
Cooperstown, NY 13326$695,000 4 Bedrooms3.5 Baths2978 SFBuilt in 1820ResidentialCooperstown Central School DistrictTaxes (School, County and Village) $7,3262 StoriesGreek Revival Style Submit an Inquiry COOPERSTOWN LANDMARKAt A New Price! One of Cooperstown’s favorite properties. Built in 1825, and locally still known as The Crooked House, even after a previous significant ...
View Details →
Land
SOLD – 118 Saddlebrook Court
Cooperstown, NY 13326 $49,500 6.04 Acres Vacant Land Otsego County Middlefield Township Cherry Valley Springfield School District Taxes (School and County) approx $578 Submit an Inquiry Come to Upstate New York and create your dream home! Ideal corner lot in Valley Views sub-division in the town of Middlefield close proximity ...
View Details →
Land
SOLD -Taylor Road
Exeter, NY 13439 $56,900 5.43 acres Vacant Land Otsego County Town of Exeter Richfield Springs School District Total Annual Taxes $766 Submit an Inquiry LAND! This is a beautiful property located in Exeter, NY. It is 5.43 acres and sits between two lovely homes just waiting for a house to ...
View Details →
Country
SOLD – Cooperstown, NY
$840,000 5 Bedrooms 3.5 Baths 3700 SF Built in 2000 Residential Middlefield Township Cherry Valley-Springfield School District Taxes (School, County and Village) $11,346 2 Stories Colonial Style Welcome Home! Architecturally designed and built by an excellent local craftsman builder in 2000, this house has sweeping views of the hills and ...
View Details →
Village
Country
Commercial
Land
Seasonal
Rentals
Buyer’s Operating Procedure
Please be advised that the Broker (Don Olin Realty, Inc.):
DOES NOT REQUIRE:
1. Prospective Buyer clients to show identification.*
2. Exclusive Buyer Broker agreements.
3. Pre-approval for a mortgage loan/proof of funds.*
*Although the Broker may not require such information, a seller of real estate may require this information prior to showing the property and/or as part of any purchase offer. The Broker may be obligated to follow the instructions of the Seller, even if it is contrary to the Broker’s procedures.
